How Are ATO Penalties Calculated and Can They Be Reduced?

ATO penalties can add tens of thousands to a tax bill. How they are calculated, when they can be reduced, and how to make a successful remission application.

When the ATO completes an audit or review and determines that you have underpaid tax, the financial consequence is rarely limited to the tax itself. On top of the additional tax assessed, the ATO will typically impose administrative penalties and General Interest Charges, which can, in serious cases, double or even triple the total amount payable.

Understanding how these penalties are calculated, and more importantly when and how they can be reduced, is essential knowledge for any taxpayer dealing with an ATO compliance matter.

The Two Types of Additional Charges: Penalties vs General Interest Charge

It is important to distinguish between two separate types of additional charges the ATO may impose.

Administrative penalties are imposed where the ATO determines you have made a false or misleading statement, have failed to lodge a required document, or have entered into a scheme to reduce your tax. Penalties are calculated as a percentage of the tax shortfall, the difference between what you paid and what the ATO says you should have paid.

General Interest Charge (GIC) is a daily interest charge that runs from the date the tax was due to the date it is paid. Unlike penalties, GIC is not discretionary. It runs automatically on unpaid tax amounts. The GIC rate is set quarterly, compounds daily, and currently sits just under 11% per annum, well above commercial interest rates. Importantly, GIC incurred on or after 1 July 2025 is no longer tax deductible, which has significantly increased the true after-tax cost of carrying an ATO debt.

How Are Administrative Penalties Calculated?

The base penalty rate depends on the nature of the taxpayer’s conduct. For a tax shortfall resulting from a failure to take reasonable care, the base penalty is 25% of the shortfall. Where the taxpayer has been reckless about the law applying to their situation, the rate increases to 50%. Where there has been intentional disregard of the law, the base penalty is 75%.

These base rates can then be increased or decreased depending on further factors. Penalties are increased where the taxpayer has a history of non-compliance. Penalties are decreased, potentially to nil, where the taxpayer has made a voluntary disclosure.

The resulting penalties can be very substantial. In one case handled by our office, a well-known Sydney franchise business was initially faced with Part 7 penalties of 200% of the unpaid superannuation guarantee charge, a figure that represented an enormous additional liability on top of the underlying SGC debt.

When Can Penalties Be Remitted?

The ATO has a broad discretion to remit, that is, reduce or eliminate, administrative penalties in appropriate circumstances. The ATO’s published guidance on remission identifies a number of relevant factors, including whether the taxpayer has a prior history of compliance, whether the taxpayer cooperated fully with the audit, and whether there were mitigating circumstances such as ill-health, financial hardship, or natural disaster.

Penalty remission is not automatic. It must be requested, and the grounds for remission must be articulated clearly and persuasively. A bare request for remission without supporting reasoning and evidence is unlikely to succeed.

In the franchise case mentioned above, our office successfully argued for full remission of the remaining 100% penalty by demonstrating that the employer had fully cooperated with the ATO, had made a voluntary disclosure, and had no prior history of non-compliance. The ATO accepted our submission and remitted the penalties in full.

Can GIC Also Be Remitted?

General Interest Charge can also be remitted in certain circumstances, though the threshold for GIC remission is higher than for penalty remission. The ATO will generally consider GIC remission where the delay in payment was caused by the ATO’s own actions, where the taxpayer has been seriously ill, or where there are other exceptional circumstances that make the full GIC charge unjust.

In practice, partial GIC remission is more common than full remission. However, even a partial remission can represent a very significant saving, particularly in cases where the tax debt is large and has been outstanding for many years. The stakes have also risen: because GIC incurred on or after 1 July 2025 is not deductible, every dollar remitted is now worth a full dollar to the taxpayer, and remitted GIC does not need to be brought back in as assessable income.

The Importance of Presentation in Remission Applications

Whether a penalty or GIC remission application succeeds often comes down to the quality and persuasiveness of the submission made. The ATO’s officers exercise genuine discretion, and a well-prepared application that clearly identifies the mitigating factors, provides supporting evidence, and engages with the relevant ATO guidelines will consistently outperform an unstructured request.

At Australian Tax Experts, we prepare remission applications that are thorough, evidence-based, and strategically framed. Our experience across hundreds of ATO matters gives us a detailed understanding of what the ATO responds to, and how to present your circumstances in the most compelling way.

Ready to Speak With a Specialist?
If you are facing ATO penalties or General Interest Charges, contact Australian Tax Experts today. We can assess your prospects for remission and manage the application process on your behalf.

Search

Categories

Recent posts

  • 1
  • …
  • 9
tax dispute resolutionPrevious Post How to Dispute an ATO Tax Assessment: Step-by-Step Guide
Next Post ATO Offshore Investigations: What You Need to Know (Video) ATO Offshore Investigations: What You Need to Know (Video)
MORE FROM US

More on this topic

Facing the ATO? Don't face them alone.

A confidential, no obligation first consultation. Early advice is the single most important step you can take.